We are a team of local insurance professionals.

Why is this so important to you? Because each one of our team, is who you will talk to in the office or on the phone. Who you will learn about your policy from. They are the face of our company. Our family. We live on Cape Cod just like you do. We are your neighborhood insurance agency.

Brian McGrath

Brian McGrath

Owner, President
Brian C. McGrath is the owner and President of E.J. McGrath Insurance Agency. A 1979 graduate of Providence College, he worked as a Commercial Insurance Underwriter in Boston for both Fireman’s Fund and AIG before moving to the Cape in 1984 to join his father, Edward, at the agency. Brian is a Massachusetts licensed Property & Casualty Insurance broker and holds the Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designation. He handles sales and customer relations.


Donna McGrath

Donna McGrath

Agency Principal
Donna, an agency principal, is the ‘back office’ of EJ McGrath Insurance. She graduated from Providence College with a B.S. in Accounting, and worked in that field until joining the agency in 2002. She handles the financial, administrative and technology components of the agency.


Sylvia White

Sylvia White

Sylvia White is a Massachusetts licensed Insurance broker as well as a Notary Public, and has been a member of the EJ McGrath Insurance staff since 2002.  Sylvia moved to Cape Cod from NYC in 1988 with her two young daughters and started her insurance career in 1989 as a receptionist for a large Cape Agency.  She quickly moved up the ranks and became a licensed insurance broker.  She has over 25 years of experience in the industry and her expertise is personal lines insurance.


Debra Wagner

Debra Wagner

Debra is a licensed agent with over 24 years of experience in the insurance industry. After attending Roger Williams University she moved home to the Cape and began her career in insurance in 1992. An expert in all lines of Property & Casualty, Debra has a specialty in personal lines coverage and customer service.


Patricia Sanzo

Patricia Sanzo

Pat has worked in the insurance industry since 1973. She is a Massachusetts licensed Insurance broker and has attained the Chartered Property Casualty Underwriter (CPCU) and Certified Insurance Counselor (CIC) designations. Pat specializes in all areas of Business Insurance and Surplus Lines Personal Insurance.


Amy Coomber Eberhardt

Amy Coomber Eberhardt

Amy, a Cape Cod native and 1994 graduate of Bridgewater State College, brings 20 years of experience to our agency. Her insurance career includes working in Claims at Commerce Insurance, and as a licensed broker at a large agency. Amy joined the E.J. McGrath Insurance Agency in 2007, and handles personal lines processing and assists in day to day customer service on personal lines accounts.